(The Independent) – A quote from James after the publication of his caffeine study neatly underlines how Oster’s attitude diverges from the attitude of the medical establishment: “Certainly, there is no evidence to suggest that caffeine benefits either mother or baby. Therefore, even if the evidence were merely suggestive, and in reality it is much stronger than that, the case for recommending caffeine be avoided during pregnancy is thoroughly compelling.” That implication — that women should only be counseled to do things that directly benefit a pregnancy, and should be told to avoid anything that could be even potentially harmful — is what irks Oster.

“I have a couple of problems with that attitude,” says Oster. “One, I think it’s not respectful. I mean, my general sense is that… women are adults, pregnant women are also adults, and we should tell people actual evidence so they can make choices for themselves.” (Read More)